Every Outage Is a Learning Opportunity

The most reliable organizations aren't the ones that never have outages — they're the ones that learn the most from each incident. Google, Netflix, and AWS all experience outages. What sets them apart is their postmortem culture: a systematic practice of analyzing incidents and turning failures into improvements.

Why Postmortems Matter

Without a postmortem, the same incident will happen again. And again. Here's what you lose without them:

  • Root causes go unaddressed: The quick fix gets the system back up, but the underlying issue remains
  • Knowledge stays siloed: The on-call engineer knows what happened, but the team doesn't
  • Patterns go unnoticed: Three similar incidents over three months look unrelated without documentation
  • Trust erodes: Customers and leadership lose confidence if the same issues keep recurring

The Blameless Postmortem

The most critical principle: blameless postmortems focus on systems, not people.

What Blameless Means

  • Not: "Who screwed up?" → Instead: "What in our system allowed this to happen?"
  • Not: "Why didn't you catch this?" → Instead: "Why didn't our monitoring catch this?"
  • Not: "This was a human error" → Instead: "Our system made it too easy for this error to occur"

People make mistakes. The goal is to build systems where mistakes are caught before they cause incidents, and where the blast radius is contained when they do.

Running the Postmortem

Timing

Hold the postmortem within 48 hours of the incident — soon enough that details are fresh, but with enough distance for emotions to settle.

Who Attends

  • The on-call engineer(s) who responded
  • The engineering manager
  • Anyone who contributed to detection, mitigation, or recovery
  • A facilitator (ideally someone not directly involved)
  • Optional: customer-facing team members who handled communications

The Agenda (60 minutes)

1. Timeline Review (15 minutes)

Walk through the incident chronologically:

  • When was the issue first detected? (By monitoring? By a user report?)
  • When was the team notified?
  • What actions were taken and when?
  • When was the issue mitigated? Resolved?

2. Root Cause Analysis (20 minutes)

Dig into why the incident happened using the "5 Whys" technique:

  • Why did the service go down? → Database connection pool exhausted
  • Why was the pool exhausted? → A query was running without a timeout
  • Why was there no timeout? → The new endpoint wasn't reviewed for query patterns
  • Why wasn't it reviewed? → We don't have a code review checklist for database queries
  • Why don't we have a checklist? → We haven't standardized our review process for data access

3. Impact Assessment (10 minutes)

  • How many users were affected?
  • What was the business impact? (Revenue, SLA breach, etc.)
  • How long was the total downtime?
  • Were there any data integrity issues?

4. Action Items (15 minutes)

For each contributing factor, identify concrete action items:

  • Immediate: What do we do this week to prevent recurrence?
  • Short-term: What do we build this quarter?
  • Long-term: What systemic changes do we need?

Each action item must have an owner and a deadline.

The Postmortem Document

Every postmortem should produce a written document. Here's a template:

Postmortem Template

  • Title: Brief description of the incident
  • Date: When the incident occurred
  • Duration: Total time from detection to resolution
  • Impact: Users affected, revenue impact, SLA status
  • Summary: 2-3 sentence overview
  • Timeline: Chronological list of events
  • Root Cause: What caused the incident and why
  • Contributing Factors: Other factors that made the incident worse
  • What Went Well: Things that worked during the response
  • What Could Be Improved: Things that slowed detection or recovery
  • Action Items: Numbered list with owners and deadlines
  • Lessons Learned: Key takeaways for the team

Common Postmortem Mistakes

1. Stopping at the Proximate Cause

"The deploy caused the outage" isn't a root cause — it's a symptom. Keep asking "why" until you reach a systemic issue.

2. Action Items Without Owners

An action item that says "improve monitoring" with no owner and no deadline will never get done. Be specific: "Add latency alerting to the checkout service — owned by Sarah — due Feb 28."

3. Skipping the Postmortem for "Small" Incidents

Small incidents reveal the same systemic issues as big ones. If anything, they're easier to learn from because the stakes are lower.

4. Not Following Up

Schedule a 2-week follow-up to verify action items are progressing. Postmortems without follow-through are just meetings.

Building Postmortem Culture

  • Start with detection: Monitor your dependencies so you detect issues early — faster detection means faster response and cleaner timelines for postmortems
  • Make it safe: Celebrate postmortems as learning events, not blame sessions
  • Share widely: Publish postmortem summaries to the broader organization
  • Track trends: Review postmortems quarterly to identify recurring themes

The best postmortem is the one that prevents the next outage.

Set up monitoring to improve detection | Build your incident response plan